All articles
3 Jan 20253 min readsitemanager

The Anti-Immigration Policy of Donald Trump Has an Australian Flavor

Australia's immigration regulations served as a model for Trump, ranging from strict restrictions for asylum seekers to deportation procedures.

341
Australia's immigration regulations served as a model for Trump, ranging from strict restrictions for asylum seekers to deportation procedures. I strolled back to my hotel along the serene Yarra River last week after witnessing the thrilling quarterfinal match between Novak Djokovic and Carlos Alcaraz at the Australian Open in Melbourne. It was beyond one in the morning. Behind me, I heard a youthful, inebriated soul sitting on a bench talking to a hairy, elderly homeless guy. I stopped to photograph the reflections of shimmering lights dancing on the river's surface.

Australia's Strict Anti-Immigrant Position

Australia has long been a model for nations looking to restrict their borders in the field of international immigration policy because of its stringent and contentious policies. US President Donald Trump, who has frequently commended Australia's tough stance, is among many who are impressed. Deterrence and stringent control are key components of Australia's immigration laws, which specifically target asylum seekers who arrive by boat. Operation Sovereign Borders, a military-led campaign started in 2013 to stop unauthorized marine landings, lies at the heart of this strategy.  The policy includes barring people who arrive by boat from ever settling in Australia, even if they are recognized as genuine refugees; forcing mandatory detention for all unauthorised arrivals, sometimes for indefinite periods; turning back boats at sea, returning asylum seekers to their country of origin or neighbouring nations; and detaining unauthorised arrivals in offshore facilities in Nauru or Papua New Guinea, often under harsh conditions. I had seen Australian naval ships speeding past us on a previous trip to the Great Barrier Reef, en route to intercept and turn away a boat full of miserable individuals who were fleeing persecution and oppression back home in search of a tranquil and fruitful life in Australia. Trump's Aussie Obsession During his previous presidency, Trump couldn't help but brag about Australia's immigration policies, particularly their tough-love approach to asylum seekers. In a 2017 phone call with then-Australian Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull, Trump declared, "You're worse than I am," clearly impressed by Australia's refusal to throw open its arms to asylum seekers. Trump initially complained about the US-Australia refugee resettlement deal, but ultimately concluded that Australia's no-nonsense approach was the gold standard for "securing the borders." The following are some significant Australian influences on Trump's immigration policies:
  1. Unauthorized entry will not be tolerated. Trump's "zero tolerance" policy, which imposed criminal penalties for anybody who crossed the US-Mexico border without authorization, was influenced by Australia's strong opposition to unapproved immigrants.
  2. Harsh Conditions for Deterrence There have been allegations of abuse, mental health issues, and even suicides in Australia's offshore detention system, which has drawn criticism for its cruel circumstances. The instance of a young girl who burned herself alive in protest at the Nauru Detention Center garnered widespread attention and criticism.
  3. Limiting Claims for Asylum Australia's laws essentially deny refuge to those who arrive by boat, either sending them to third countries or detaining them offshore permanently.
  4. Emphasis on Immigration Based on Merit Through a "points-based system," which gives preference to candidates with high levels of education, job experience, and English proficiency, Australia's immigration system prioritizes skilled migrants.
  5. Policies Regarding Deportations Non-citizens, even permanent residents, may be deported under Section 501 of the Migration Act of Australia if they fail a "character test," such as having a criminal record. Trump also made deporting illegal immigrants and non-citizens with criminal histories a priority, arguing that they posed a threat to public safety. Other nations aiming for more stringent border restrictions have also been impacted by Australia's immigration approach. Adoption of such practices globally runs the danger of undermining international human rights and refugee protection standards.

Read next